The process of scientific manuscript evaluation in high impact journal
                     SEP 27,2019
Research Paper
PROCESS OF A SCIENTIFIC  
MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION IN A HIGH- 
 IMPACT JOURNAL
What Matter’s for Editors & Peer reviewers
Tag: # Manuscript Evaluation # Scientific Research # Peer Review # Plagiarism Check
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
KEY POINTS
Manuscript Evaluation
Manuscript Valuations-Important Facts  
Process - Manuscript Evaluation in Journals
Export questions – Evaluation process 
 Summary
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION
Manuscript evaluation is an in-depth, developmental, 
and  structural editing report.
It provides a bigger picture of the manuscript by deeply 
 analyzing its facts.
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
MANUSCRIPT  
VALUATIONS-IMPORTANT 
 FACTS
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
01 Structure & Organization
02 Exposition
03 Clarity of ideas
Manuscript Valuations
04 Point of View
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
01 Structure & 
01 Organization
Structure of the manuscript should be as  
per the authors guidelines and also for  
02 easy reading and understanding.
03
Organization will enhance the
04 comprehension of the manuscript to prove
the responsibility of the researcher in
providing  effective research and
05 manuscript.
06
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
Common Convention - Scientific
Manuscripts
02 Exposition 03 Clarity of ideas 04 Point of view
It theimportant  Manuscript should have Manuscript should have
reveals  ref (citations)and clarity, brevity, and logic in  a  clear point  of
erences  ba information the way the question  vreieswearch anodf thsehould
ckground  u thescientific arrives,  methods  used    to proceeding be  within
sedfor  res
earch. solve it, and the perspective of tthe research  
conclusions. at all times of writing the  
manuscript.
Use simple language and  Avoid irrelevant information, 
observe the rules of good   no matter how strongly you  
grammar, linguistic style,  like it.
punctuation and spelling.
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
PROCESS - MANUSCRIPT 
 EVALUATION IN  
JOURNALS
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
Choosing a suitable journal. 01
Check word count, 
02 formatting, tables,  and figures and 
media.
Do not submit it two journals 03
 simultaneously.
Identify& submit it to right journal, author  
04 gets an acknowledgement after 
submission  of manuscript for evaluation.
Manuscript is checked by the Editor-in-  
chief (EIC), whether it fits into the aim and 05
 scope of the journal and assess your  
manuscript. Plagiarism check for the similarity of 06 the  article with any 
previously published.
Then evaluated by peer reviewers as an  07
essential process to guarantee its scientific A positive report 
 validity. 08 from the peer reviews,  the manuscripts
 are taken 
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
for further  evaluations of the other 
sections.
EXPORT  
QUESTIONS – MANUSCRIPT
EVALUATION PROCESS
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
Vit a lit y Will
Methods Is t h e  s t r a t eg y  of 
R es ea rch   of Major  issues  t h e  r esu l t s  help  in  
to  a n s w er  t h e   t h e  co r rec t  a n d  
 m a n u scr ipt  wi th   t h e   advanc ing  t h e   
 quest ion?  viable?
quest ion  ?  quest ion? methods? concerned  field ?
Appropr ia te   Does impor t ance  of  Will 
Conclusions  
Evidence  provided Methods,  d a t a  &  a d v a n ce s  in  field a r e  o t he r   r e s ea r che r
ana l yz ed  a n d  
 in  proof of t h e   exper imen t s  t h a t   up  t o  t h e  s t a n d a r d s  s  
 i n t e rp re ted   
conclusions?  an s we r s   of t h e show  i n t e r e s t in  
correct ly?
r e s ea r ch   journal? read ing   
quest ion? r e s ea r ch   
manusc r ip t?
Are in te res t ed   Does Is manu s c r ip t  c l ea r  
Is ma n u s c r i p t wr i t t en Is l anguage w r i t t en   
W h a t  k ind  of  
t h e  ma nu sc r i p t  fit    in  i t s  r e s e a r c h  & to  well  us ing impeccable in  ma n u s c r i p t  is  r e s ea r ch e r s  will be r e s ea r che r s  will be 
 in t e res ted  in  t h e    p a r t  of journal 's   well  t oge the r  in  al l  
 w h a t  re su l t s  m e a n  o Engl i sh & sound & super ior 
 aspec ts? t   field? wi thou t   a n y  for  e a s y readabi l i ty s tudy? aud iences? g r a mma t i c a l   a n d   unde r s t and ing?
mis t akes?
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
SUMMARY
" The process of manuscript evaluation with all the above 
 facts evaluated and the questions answered will get 
more  chances of being published in reputed and 
renowned  journals."
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
PUBRICA LAB @ 
 
PUBRICA.COM
www.research.pubrica.com
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved
PHONE NUMBER
UK : +44-1143520021
INDIA : +91 9884350006
EMAIL ADDRESS GET IN  
[email protected] TOUCH WITH 
 US
Copyright © 2019 Pubrica. All rights reserved