Uploaded on Feb 24, 2020
Retrospective vs Prospective Study: Advantages, Types and Differences. https://www.cognibrain.com/retrospective-vs-prospective-study-advantages-types-and-differences/
Retrospective vs Prospective Study
Retrospectiv
e vs.
Prospective
Study
What is a
Retrospective Study?
Retrospective, the term comprises two
words i.e. “retro” which means “in the
past” and “spective” which means “to
look”. Thus, a retrospective analyzes
the events of information that had
already occurred in the past. In a
retrospective study, the outcome of the
reference studies has already occurred
before a retrospective study is initiated.
The researcher or an author of a
retrospective study can collect the data
from the registry. In a retrospective
study, after the collection of data, the
research question is framed.
What are the
Advantages of
Retrospective Study?
Less time consuming and
cheaper: Retrospective studies are
cheaper and require less time for
completion. As the data related to the
study is already available and the
researcher compiles and compares the
data between and subjects and control,
retrospective studies provide immediate
results.
Effective in rare
disease: Retrospective study is quiet
effective in rare diseases. Data related
to the rare disease is available from
various centres to arrive at an
evaluable study population.
Initial screening: Sometimes the
retrospective studies are done as an
initial screening for prospective
studies.
No-follow-up: Retrospective studies
uses the data already available in the
literature or the registry. Thus, there
is no risk of loss of follow-up in
retrospective studies.
Large data-set: Retrospective
makes use of large data-set. This
may provide more accurate results.
What are the Types of
Retrospective Studies?
Retrospective cohort studies: This
study is also known as the historic
cohort study.
Case series and case reports: Case
reports are a type of retrospective
study in which the researcher reports
symptoms or instructive case that was
not previously seen with a medical
condition.
Case-Control Studies: Case-control
studies are better than case series and
case reports.
What is a Prospective
Study?
Prospective studies are done in the
present to analyze the outcome in the
future. In the prospective study, the
information is required to be generated
and is not available before the start of
the study. An example of a prospective
study is to follow-up with a group of
alcohol drinkers to identify whether
drinking alcohol for 10-years is linked to
liver disease. It is to be noted that none
of the subjects enrolled under the study
should have the outcome of interest.
For instance, in the above example,
none of the subjects should have liver
disease before the start of the study.
What are the
Advantages of
Prospective Study?
New disease risk
factors: Prospective studies are
important in analyzing the risk factors
for new diseases for which the data is
not available. This will help in the
effective management of the disease.
Accurate results: Because of well-
controlled study design and accurate
generation of data, the results
provided by prospective studies are
relatively more authentic.
Detailed data analysis: Detailed
analysis of the outcome and other
statistical factors can be done in
prospective studies. Exposure can be
measured before the outcome and
the incidence and disease process
can also be determined.
Multiple outcomes: Multiple
outcomes can also be obtained from
prospective studies.
No risk of recall bias: As the
prospective study does not require
any data recollection from the past,
the risk of recall bias is eliminated.
What are the Various
Types of Prospective
Studies?
Prospective trend studies: In this
study, the samples are taken from the
dynamic population in which the
individuals change over time.
Prospective panel studies: In such
studies, the measurement is done on
the same set of individuals.
Prospective cohort studies: In the
prospective cohort studies, the
measurement is done on the
individuals from the same pool of
individuals.
What is the Difference
between Retrospective and
Prospective Study?
Data: In the prospective study the data
is generated by the researcher after
enrollment of the subjects while
retrospective studies make use of the
already available information.
Control: Prospective study has more
control over the subjects and data
generation as compared to retrospective
studies.
Accuracy: More accurate results are
provided by prospective studies due to
less biasness and optimum data control.
Time and cost: Prospective studies are
more time-consuming and costlier as
compared to retrospective studies.
Biasness: The risk of recall biasness is
eliminated in prospective studies.
Practicality: Prospective studies are
both observational and interventional
while retrospective studies are only
observational.
Usefulness: Prospective studies are
useful in cases of emerging new
exposures while retrospective studies
are not of much use in such scenarios.
Email ID:
[email protected]
Phone: 044-49595223
Visit us:
https://www.cognibrain.com/
Comments