ChatGPT Essay Writer vs Essay Writing Services - A Comparative Analysis
                     ChatGPT Essay Writer vs Essay Writing
Services - A Comparative Analysis
Prompting a ChatGPT essay writer to craft an academic essay has become a cause of concern 
in the academic community now. As Forbes recognises, tutors worldwide are battling 
plagiarism as reportedly 89% of students use ChatGPT for the generation of their essays 
and homework. 
Evidently, ChatGPT has initiated a cultural shift in the way students work, learn and write. 
As the workload in colleges and universities around the globe is increasing regularly and 
daily, so are the levels of academic stress and anxiety among the students. To minimise their 
stress levels, students opt for a number of ways that assist them in managing their workload 
effectively.
One of the most popular options available to students is the outsourcing. The trust ratio of 
students is relatively higher on reliable essay writing help as compared to the generative 
tools. The results of a survey titled ‘Analysing the students' views, concerns, and perceived 
ethics about ChatGPT usage’ show that more than 50% of the participants believed that 
using ChatGPT essay writer websites for the completion of exams and assignments falls in 
the category of cheating. 
In this article, we shall discuss the power and weaknesses of ChatGPT essay writing and see 
how human writers can impact students' academic success in ways that other tools are unable 
to do so. 
Can You Use ChatGPT to Write Essays?
Per the insights offered by Harvard Summer School, you can use the predictive text features 
of ChatGPT to write your essays. ChatGPT creates new text content based on the past data 
that is fed into the system. When you use the right prompts, you can create the required data 
from this platform within seconds. However, the integrity of such data is questionable 
because it is generated by the analysis of existing data patterns. Also, the ChatGPT essay 
writers fail to give accurate citations of the sources they use, so the reliability of their essay 
content is highly doubtful. 
How to Use ChatGPT to Write an Essay Without Plagiarising?
The process of generating an essay with the help of ChatGPT essay writer is simple. You get 
a homework essay; you open ChatGPT and ask it to craft a six-paragraph academic essay on 
the topic you have been provided with. After a wait of a few seconds, you get a well-written 
academic essay with this tool.
But is it all really that easy? It is important to note that ChatGPT is in the early stages of its 
development and it is likely to commit so many basic errors in the papers it crafts. Before you
start trusting ChatGPT essay rewriters, keep yourself aware of its drawbacks. Even the 
generative model itself warns the users that ChatGPT may give inaccurate or false 
information to users about people, places, and things. 
ChatGPT Essay Writer vs Essay Writing Services - Which Is the Best Option 
for Students?
As the AI writing tools allure the attention of students, the ratio of their users has been 
increasing day by day. As the report titled ChatGPT: A Meta-Analysis After 2.5 Months 
states, ChatGPT gained over 100 million subscribers in the course of 2 months after its 
release in November 2022. 
Before 2021, the world of AI text generation was considered uncharted territory, and fairly, it
is still in its early stages of development. To understand how ChatGPT works and how 
students can use it to get academic assistance, we have to look at the features of the tool. 
The Features of ChatGPT
The huge shift in the deployment and evolution of Natural Language Generation (NLG) tools 
has yielded a global discussion about the future of the academic world. The interesting thing 
is that despite being a powerful AI tool, ChatGPT was primarily designed for conversational 
purposes and text generation. Its development has not been focussed on the specialised needs 
of academic essay writing. 
1. Natural Language Generation
Users employ ChatGPT to generate natural-sounding language to add the human touch to the 
essays it crafts. NLG mimics human speech patterns and analyses the structure of human 
language. Using this technique, ChatGPT essay writers create content which resembles that 
of humans but is actually AI-written. Several universities have restrictions on the inclusion of
AI-generated content in essays submitted by students. 
2. Knowledge Base Integration
A ChatGPT essay writer works by integrating with the knowledge bases for the provision of 
relevant and accurate information to the users. Due to the access it has to various knowledge 
bases, ChatGPT can provide detailed information and answers to students' complex 
questions. Usually, students in finance and healthcare rely on AI tools because they provide 
accurate information to the users.
3. Sentiment Analysis
The third prominent feature of a ChatGPT essay writer is that they try to analyse the 
sentiments of the conversations and queries and reply appropriately. By the robotic analysis 
of the language and tone used in a conversation is complete, these AI writers determine the 
mood of the user. Based on the writing prompts, they generate the required data for students. 
This feature comes in handy when the user is managing the customer support department and 
not an official academic essay.
4. Automatic Summarisation
A ChatGPT essay writer is good at summarising long texts, making it easy for them to digest 
large amounts of information and write concise texts. By analysing the text and identifying 
the highlights and key points, ChatGPT generates a summary that captures the essence of the 
main text and uses that in the response to prompt users. The process is usually quick and 
saves users time. 
Drawbacks and Limitations of ChatGPT in Academic Essay Writing
Per a research paper titled A large-scale comparison of human-written versus ChatGPT-
generated essays, there are a few drawbacks to work crafted by any ChatGPT essay writer. 
Apart from the drawbacks, a couple of limitations of using AI tools for generating essays are 
mentioned here: 
1. Problems With Selective Subjects
In an OpenAI report published by Cornell University, the performance of ChatGPT for the 
Advanced Placement (AP) classes of the US academic system was assessed. The researchers 
used diverse subjects for the evaluation. The results showed that a ChatGPT essay writer 
could not perform well in various subjects, such as English literature, macroeconomics, 
physics, chemistry, and statistics. The interpretation of AI for certain subject terms was 
wrong. 
2. Issues With the Soundness of Assessments
Secondly, the researchers found issues with the soundness of the assessment of the essays, 
which went beyond the conflict of interest. The results were too generalised to be valued by 
the scientific community in the academia. The content that a ChatGPT essay writer used in 
the essays was ambiguous, too vague or too generalised. 
3. Questionable Scientific Judgements
While the research paper states that almost 2 of the 3rd-party contractors took part in the 
rating of responses provided by a ChatGPT essay writer, there is no information on how such 
ratings were produced for the replies of prompts and what the reliability criteria are. This lack
of crucial information led to questionable scientific judgements, which also affected the 
quality of the academic papers and essays generated by ChatGPT. 
4. AI-Structured Templates
Lastly, the owners of the AI models have guided the robotic writers to write academic essays 
in the form of structured templates. The templates make the answers similar for all kinds of 
questions, and this leads to doubts about the accuracy of the information used by the 
ChatGPT essay writer. These writers just fill in the data in templates, and as a result, such 
essays need more creativity from expert human writers. 
Understanding the Basics of Essay Writing Services
Before providing you with the ChatGPT vs essay writing services comparison, understand 
how essay services work and how the work of a human writer differs from that of a ChatGPT 
essay writer. An essay writing service primarily exists to help researchers, students, and even 
professional writers produce high-quality and customised academic content. 
1. Writing Specifications
The most notable characteristics of academic essay writing are the formal tone, rigorous 
evidence standards, and the clear focus on arguments that it must behold. Such services 
employ experienced human essay writers who possess an advanced understanding of 
different academic fields. Such writers come from professional academic backgrounds. 
2. Commitment to Originality 
Another significant feature of online essay writing services is that they are committed to 
providing original content to students. Plagiarism has serious consequences in the academic 
world. Unlike AI tools, expert human writers ensure the provision of well-researched, unique 
and properly cited content. They also check your papers with anti-plagiarism software before 
submitting them to you. 
3. Customisation of Content
The third most unique feature of essay help services is that they can craft customised essay 
content for their customers. AI models generate academic content based on the writing 
prompts and the data fed into them. Human writers can adopt a personal approach and take 
into account the needs, ideas and feedback of each client while writing such papers. The 
creativity of expert human writers makes them best suited to get online help with your papers.
4. Guidance and Mentorship
Lastly, essay writing services can provide individual guidance and mentorship to clients. 
Many such services provide advice and resources to clients on improving their writing skills, 
understanding the tough demands of essay writing, and guiding them on the process of 
academic publication. The AI platforms, no matter how advanced they are, lack the ability to 
offer mentorship opportunities to students. 
ChatGPT vs Essay Writing Services: Why Can ChatGPT Essay Writer Not 
Replace Human Essay Writing Services?
Now that we have evaluated the performance of a ChatGPT essay writer and explored the 
limitations of AI essay writing tools, it is time to present a final comparative analysis between
both choices. Is the ChatGPT as revolutionary as people think it is, or is it lacking true 
intelligence? Let’s see the analysis presented below. 
1. The Difference in Writing Styles
The writing styles of human writers and ChatGPT essay writers differ greatly. For example, 
the latter works on ChatGPT essay writing prompts, while the former uses creative research 
faculties to create content that meets clients' academic standards. The work crafted by the AI 
models contains more nominalisations, and the sentence complexity is much higher compared
to that of human writers. 
2. No Intelligence, Mere Statistics
One of the most popular misconceptions about ChatGPT essay writers is that they have a 
degree of human intelligence. However, the intelligence of such writers is merely their ability
to do the statistical analysis of the text. The apparently original essays crafted by the essay 
writers are not written after deep research but by merely identifying the patterns that already 
exist in the data and work. The human essay writers craft essays after conducting in-depth 
research. 
3. AI Hallucination’
A ChatGPT essay writer often provides false information to the extent that the term ‘AI 
Hallucination’ has been coined for it. Even the generative model has a warning about the 
provision of inaccurate information by the tool. Contrary to that, writers of essay writing 
services cross-check the information and evaluate the reliability of the sources before they 
use them for work. They also add the sources of information in the bibliography or reference 
list they craft for the essays. 
4. Skirting the Plagiarism Problem
A ChatGPT essay writer gets their essay content from a large library of information that has 
already been present and sometimes add the same information in their papers without citing 
it. Isn’t it plagiarism? Per the findings of a research paper titled Academic Writing and 
ChatGPT, the integrity within academic writing concerning the use of ChatGPT prompts has 
sparked conversation in academia. Unlike these models, professional essay writing services 
provide plagiarism-free content to their users. 
5. No Research Involved
The writers at essay writing services research their sources and cite them at the end of the 
papers they craft per the citation style recommended by students. The research is an essential 
ingredient in the recipe of successful essays by such websites. 
On the other hand, if you ask a ChatGPT essay writer or other rewriter tools to cite sources 
for you, they will either be made up or inaccurate. It is because they do not know how to look
for relevant research resources that can be applied to your essays. There are no checks on 
data quality control. 
6. Data Privacy Issues
When you place your essay order with the websites, they usually provide you with a 
guarantee that your private and academic details shall stay safe with them. But with 
ChatGPT, it is different. When you input your data into any AI model, you will have no clue 
about the ownership of your information. So, there are concerns with the privacy and 
confidentiality of your personal and academic details with a ChatGPT essay writer. 
Conclusion
The bottom line is that ChatGPT and other generative AI tools are here to stay and they shall 
most probably go a long way, but even then, they cannot replace the experience of human 
essay writers. A ChatGPT essay writer only provides you with a quick robotic report and tries
to reflect human-like tendencies in the work but it lacks the creativity of a human mind. Also,
it has not yet evolved into its best form, so the drawbacks are probably more than the benefits
of using AI. 
With that being said, it is important to communicate your research and ideas in the essays you
craft. You can utilise AI tools like ChatGPT to support your academic pursuits but it is 
advisable to not rely upon them blindly. In order to get original papers, trusting professional 
essay writing services is far safer than having faith in generative tools.