Reasons for Manuscript Rejection in a journal. Why does a PhD Scholar need Manuscript Writing Help? - Phdassistance
                     R E A S O N S F O R
M A N U S C R I P T R E J E C T I 
O N  I N A J O U R N A L .
W H Y D O E S A P H D S C H O L A 
R  N E E D M A N U S C R I P 
T
W R I T I N G H E L P
An Academic presentation by
Dr. Nancy Agnes, Head, Technical Operations, 
Phdassistance  Group www.phdassistance.com
Email: [email protected]
TODAY'S 
DISCUSSION
Outlin
In Brief about why a Manuscript Rejected?
e
Introduct ion about Common Reasons for Manuscript Rejection
Why Does a PhD Scholar need Manuscript  Writ ing Help 
 Definitions
Requirements and Approval 
 Acknowledgements  
Conclusion
In-
Brief
The editorial board of a journal usually makes decisions on which publications are written.
Manuscripts are refused at one of two stages in the approval process for most  
publications. An editorial dismissal is the first step. The journal editor issues this kind of  
denial, which usually occurs within 12 weeks of submission. At this point, editors reject  
manuscripts for one or more technical reasons: The manuscript is lacking key elements or 
 portions that the journal needs. The Instructions to Authors usually explain the essential  
elements or parts. The manuscript topic is not likely to concern the chosen journal’s  
readership or falls short of its Aims and Scope. There is a lack of scholarship in the paper.
It is insufficiently cited, lacks or fails to mention relevant literature in the field, or the  
sources are out of date. Parts of the text may have been plagiarized, according to the 
 article, PhD Manuscript Peer review of journal.
Introductio
A manuscript can be rejected for various purposes, but
n the  most common ones are technical and editorial.
TECHNICAL REASONS FOR REJECTION INCLUDE:
Incomplete evidence, such as a limited sample size,  
missing or inadequate controls
Inadequate analysis, such as the use of incorrect  
mathematical measures or a complete lack of statistics  
Inappropriate technique for addressing your hypothesis 
 or the use of an outdated Methodology that has been  
superseded by modern, more efficient approaches that  
provide more reliable results.
Contd...
BELOW ARE SOME OF THE EDITORIAL REASONS FOR REJECTION:
Research ethics, such as patient consent or ethics committee approval for animal 
 research, are ignored.
Inadequate structure or failure to adhere to journal formatting requirements
Due to a lack of necessary detail, readers cannot entirely comprehend and repeat 
 the authors’ interpretation and experiment.
A lack of current sources or references with a high percentage of self-citations 
 It is written in a weak language that audiences are unable to comprehend.
Contd...

Why Does 
a  PhD 
Scholar  
need  
The Manuscript Choice is thought to be a good 
Manuscrip  substitute for a standard dissertation text.
t  Writing 
Help The student profits from the manuscript choice  because it adds to their publishing record.
Definitio
ns Writing in the style, substance, and structure of a  
particular Peer-Reviewed, professional Journal  ap
propriate to the Manuscript’s content is described as  
“suitable for publication.”
The manuscripts do not have to be sent for submission or 
 written to be considered suitable for publication.
When a manuscript is deemed ready for submission, the 
 student’s counselor takes the final call and the advisor  
may seek feedback from the PhD Manuscript Writing
Services committee before making a decision.
Requiremen
ts  and The research had to be done under the supervision of 
Approval  a University graduate faculty member.
During the dissertation, the recipient must be enrolled 
 for the requisite graduation credits at the university.
The student’s advisor and PhD Dissertation Manuscrip
t  Writing Help Committee must sign off on the  
manuscript choice in writing, and they are responsible  
for guiding the substance of the entire dissertation,
including the manuscripts.
Contd...
The student’s counsellor approves the material in the end.
The manuscript choice should be accepted as soon as their research subject has 
 been approved, ideally before the research begins.
Manuscripts: A minimum of two and a maximum of three publishable manuscripts 
 are required.
At least one manuscript must be data-driven and report new/unique details of the 
 study’s key findings. On all manuscripts, the student should be the first author.
Acknowledgements
An introductory chapter – at a minimum, it  
introduces the dissertation’s general topic,
 describes how the manuscripts and
 approach  the chapters  themeand explain how
manuscripts relate toth oene another.
The introduction should also address the general  
need and relevance of the research subject and  
analysis and the uniqueness of the results.
Contd...
Specific material — The following information should be used in one of the  
manuscripts or as a separate chapter: a summary of relevant literature; a theoretical  
framework/model/theory; a summary of the methods, including concept, hypothesis,  
procedures, and research plan; relevant primary and secondary observations,  
including the required form of supporting evidence and analysis/statistical outcomes,  
and hypotheses relating to specific findings, including an understanding of the  
significance of the specific findings and a comparison to previous literature.
Synthesis chapter – at a minimum, a synthesis and analysis of the study’s overall  
results that demonstrates the incorporation of the material of both manuscripts and  
chapters and an appreciation of the unifying thread, discussion of the whole collection  
of findings’ new/original relevance to the body of research, and a clarification of the  
manuscripts’ significance concerning the main subject.
Contd...
References – based on the publication for which the text is intended,
each  manuscript may have its collection of references.
The type of references in the manuscripts may vary from one another
for  Proofreading Editing Services UK,
Conclusion
The conclusion has aspects in common with the debate,  
and the two pieces are often merged (especially in shorter  
papers and journal articles).
However, it is customary to include a final chapter in a  
dissertation that summarizes your thesis and provides a  
final impression of the research to the reader.
The conclusion chapter should be more generic and  
shorter than the discussion chapter.
Rather than explaining concrete conclusions and  
analyzing the data in depth, you make general comments  
that summarize the research’s most critical findings.
Contact Us
UNITED KINGDOM
+44-1143520021
INDIA
+91-4448137070
EMAIL
[email protected]